My original gym was in the UK and is fully upgraded. As it was full, I opened a new UK gym and fully upgraded it. It has a global rep and plenty of space, but when I sign amateurs, they only go to the overfilled first gym
Yeah just a bug I think mate. Same with signing heavyweights at the minute, they start at rank 900 and ask for rank 350 after 5 fights which is impossible.
The first gym you make will be where the amateurs go if both gyms are same nation. Sure it will be fixed in due time.